England’s Rugby Captain and a Modest Proposal for English Football

First posted MyT March 8th 2009 – revised and reposted tonight  to pass the time before the Six Nations kicks off. Revised again for displacement activity on 29/11/11

Some time ago,  I had a brilliant idea for how  the English football  team  could win the World Cup, possibly in perpetuity. Being a Scot, I tried to forget it but it kept popping back. I think I should share it with you as it could have the side effect of saving England, which is probably, on balance, a ‘good thing’.

In bowls, there is no nationality rule. You play for the country you live  in. Thus, one of the mainstays of the English bowls team for years was Andy Thomson from Fife who still speaks with an accent that makes Naughtie sound Cockney.  Over in Australia, the former World Number 1, David Gourlay from Ayrshire, walked straight into their team as soon as he emigrated.Apply the logic. England undoubtedly has the best league in the word and many of the best players, most of whom are not English. You already have an Italian manager so it is no great leap to have an England team that is full of foreigners as well. I think the FA should lodge a rule change with FIFA at the earliest opportunity suggesting that football uses the same qualification as bowls.

The thing is that I think you might get away with it. The other national associations are all going to be too proud to admit that their leagues are inferior. Then you have the Sepp Blatter factor. The man is a complete nutter, ever ready to adopt some off the wall scheme -see Qatar 2022. He might be feeling a tad guilty about all the bid nonsense and he might just agree that you have a real cracker of an idea this time.

If he buys it, the proposal could guarantee England the Word Cup in perpetuity. This is where I think it gets interesting. The political correctness of the established parties means that they will try to interfere with the selection of the team by insisting that the team is representative of our multi-cultural country. The English are indeed a people that are slow to anger but mucking about with their football team could be the spark which finally lit the fuse.  The barricades of white vans would be on the streets immediately.

A tsunami of outrage could sweep away the establishment and might even swamp the monarchy. We know that Her Majesty is on record as saying that she is not very keen on football –  remember Tommy Cooper asking her for her Cup Final ticket when she told him that? Give a football to her heir and he would only try to engage it in conversation. One of his boys probably supports Germany and the other one is an Aston Villa fan, which isn’t much better, in my opinion.

Were the Windsors forced into exile, you have a ready-made replacement waiting across the water. ‘King David I and Queen Victoria’ has a certain ring, and you would have a King Brooklyn coming up next (good for trying to re-invigorate the special relationship) with the Princes Romeo and Cruz (and now Princess Harper Seven) to keep the tabloids happy. King David could personally lead the team into action so we could all forget the quiz question about George II and the otherwise unremarkable battle of Dettingen.

You’d obviously have to leave the EU straight away to stop them claiming that free movement of labour meant that players living in England could choose to play for other parts of the Union. You’d also have to withdraw from the Convention on Human Rights in order to gain complete control of your borders. The only criterion for entry would be soccer skill. Lob a football at every immigrant and if they can’t keep it in the air for at least a minute, then send them straight back where they came from. You can also test their English by asking them to explain the offside rule.

Tear up the Kyoto agreement. I admit that, if there is a weakness in my scheme, it is that the first few England sides will be almost all foreign, but open up the pits and the traditional  industries again and you will soon have a fresh supply of Millburns and Charltons. As a bonus, English cricket could find new Larwoods and Truemans.

Build industrial slums on all the playing fields in the Northern cities. Take away the kids’ mobile phones and computers and  issue them with empty tin cans. Then force them to kick said cans around the mean, cobbled streets in impromptu 20 a side games for at least two hours every day, except the Sabbath. This will cut into the alcohol-consuming hours available and tire them out which should reduce their levels of violence to a manageable level. Close all the faith schools and replace them with King David  I Soccer Academies. Make everybody under 18 study the Laws of Association Football every day of the week (except the Sabbath, of course).

With these few,simple changes, you will soon have a cadre of fit young English people whose only desire is to play professional football. The standard of the game will shoot up in every League division and the glut of footballers will mean that the law of supply and demand brings down the obscene level of wages being paid and admission charges. The crowds will flock back to the game and will  reach pre-war levels. The recession will come to an end with a building boom as stadia are rebuilt and enlarged. The wool, cotton and clothing industries will be revived by a surge in production of replica strips and retro gear such as flat caps. A new generation of artists will, like Lowry, find their inspiration in grim, industrial landscapes.

Starting from now, you would obviously have to rely on the foreigners for 2018 but I am sure that you would be able to field a world-class side that was almost entirely English by the time you retained it  2022. The rest of the British Isles will, I am sure, wish you well.

The Welsh will have rugby with a fresh supply of forwards from the re-opening of their pits. The Irish can concentrate on Gaelic football and that aberrant version of shinty that they persist in playing. The Manxmen can carry on playing ‘Pin the tail on the cat’ and running three-legged races and the Channel Islands may well embark on an ambitious research programme to produce clones of Matt Le Tissier (but the clones will not get as many England caps as they should).

And whaur stands proud Scotia in all of this, I hear you ask? Well, we’ll always have the curling and the said bowls. But, I have to admit that I have a hidden agenda. I reckon that we could get the Princess Royal as monarch of Scotland out of the fall of the House of Windsor – she is, after all, the best man for the job of all of the Queen’s brood. We could then reintroduce the old Pictish practice of passing the succession down through the female line and look forward to the reign of Queen Zara.

The prospect of being able to watch her consort, Prince Mike Tindall of Gloucester and England, having to stand to attention at Murrayfield to sing ‘Flower of Scotland’ through gritted teeth more than makes up for all those future English Word Cups.

12 thoughts on “England’s Rugby Captain and a Modest Proposal for English Football”

  1. I darn well wish I knew more about this, Mr Mackie.

    I really do detect a flaw in your usually impeccable logic, but I’m not sure quite how to tackle it. 😦

  2. Good evening John-Boy

    Seems quite heavily revised from the early draft. Wasn’t Beckham King of the USA or some such in the original? Too much in here for me to digest before my dinner (just back from fives), for example is James Hewitt a Villa supporter.

    Scotland will always be the best in the world at hammer-throwing as exemplified by the Heart of Midlothian players at Ibrox on Wednesday. El Hadji Diouf for First Minister. Be back after a big dinner and after watching another episode of The Waltons on DVD. I’ve came round to your way of thinking and The W’s have usurped Little House on the Prairie as best TV prog ever.

  3. Brilliant as your scheme is, JM, it would infringe the “yooman rights” of the African countries. Their main claim to fame, and the only reason they can compete internationally, is because of the likes of – come on, someone think of an African equivalent of Pele! (The only names I can think of are Thierry Henry, Zidane, Drogba and they’re French and too old.) So I don’t think your plan would be accepted – loud cries of “colonialism” and so on. Husband suggests that England really couldn’t cope with winning anything anyway because it’s been so long since they did.

    Better to get rid of the foreign manager – he’s not been much good, has he? – and bring in Alex Ferguson or Dalglish (Kenny’s the wee man!)

    If we do get the Princess Royal to rule Scotland, and I agree she’s the best man for the job, then the Scottish team would get to sing “God save the Queen” and the English could go and find their own anthem.

  4. Very astute, JM
    Guessing that I would be unmoved by a post about Rugger or Soccer, you sneakily incorporated the noble game of Lawn Bowls, which is the passion of every Queenslander – in a quiet, unassuming way, of course, as befits our State character.

    I cannot place too much faith in the Mackie plan for world conquest, and am, to be honest, rather more concerned with the revolution that is long overdue downunder – but it will happen – against the current reigning house of Cricket Australia.

    But an interesting read, nonetheless. 😆

  5. “If we do get the Princess Royal to rule Scotland, and I agree she’s the best man for the job, then the Scottish team would get to sing “God save the Queen”

    Sheona, I agree wholeheartedly with your statement.

  6. Araminta :

    I darn well wish I knew more about this, Mr Mackie.

    I really do detect a flaw in your usually impeccable logic, but I’m not sure quite how to tackle it. :(

    I take it that you realise that I will now not be able to sleep tonight. A flaw? In my logic? It’s a worry!

    I’ll just have a wee initial stab to pass the time.I hope that it’s not about us Scots adopting a monarchical solution with Annie (the First) ending up as Queen of Jockland? As you can see from JW, Sheona and me myself, there is a lot of respect for the Princess Royal up here. President of the Scottish Rugby Union and she appears at most games at Murrayfield enthusiastically belting out ‘God Save My Mum’ amd ‘Flower of Jockland’ with equal gusto.

    If it’s not that, please ‘tackle’ whatever it is and make me aware thereof. I really need to know. It’s a Jock thing.

  7. theroyalist :

    Good evening John-Boy

    Seems quite heavily revised from the early draft. Wasn’t Beckham King of the USA or some such in the original? Too much in here for me to digest before my dinner (just back from fives), for example is James Hewitt a Villa supporter.

    Scotland will always be the best in the world at hammer-throwing as exemplified by the Heart of Midlothian players at Ibrox on Wednesday. El Hadji Diouf for First Minister. Be back after a big dinner and after watching another episode of The Waltons on DVD. I’ve came round to your way of thinking and The W’s have usurped Little House on the Prairie as best TV prog ever.

    Aye right, JW. I personally feel that those yellow-carded Heart of Midlothian players were representing the whole of Scotland when they attempted to take out El Hadji Diouf before he infected Scottish football with the evil, spitting, torn-faced, waste of space that he is. I could, of course, be wrong but I have to tell you that I am quite close to wanting the Unmentionables to get a draw against you on Sunday.

    I’ll probably get over such lunancy in time, but he is still a total scumbag, in my opinion.

  8. Bearsy :

    Very astute, JM
    Guessing that I would be unmoved by a post about Rugger or Soccer, you sneakily incorporated the noble game of Lawn Bowls, which is the passion of every Queenslander – in a quiet, unassuming way, of course, as befits our State character.

    Hi, Bearsy and this is important. Do you unassuming Queenslanders play the great game in your winter?

    It is becoming increasingly clear that, if Mrs M gets her way, we will be over in your neck of the woods for July of this year to visit her brother. That’s right in the middle of our competitive bowling season and I have made it clear that I am not very happy about that at all, at all. Losing the battle!

    It would help ease the grief if I knew that OZ greens would be open then.

  9. Mr M:

    I am afraid your whole argument falls down on the assumption that the English Premier League is the best Soccer League in the world. If it were, many more English teams would win international tournaments.

    Anyway, Rugby (either code) is a much better game. 🙂

  10. Dear Mr. Mackie,

    Your “no sitting on the fence” stance would give the legendary James Sanderson no cause to spiral in his grave but I disagree with your river Forthright view. While not condoning the previous actions of the First minister, I’m with Super Ally on this one in letting the Bygone days of Yore be the Bygone days of Yore. I’d recommended you read Mark 11:25.

    A draw tomorrow and the subsequent replay would help, in a small way, the perilous finances of Scotland’s greatest institution. However, I’d prefer a Diouf hat-trick.

Add your Comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: