A very European road to perdition -revisited!

In January 2011 I wrote ”A very European Road to Perdition’, which I posted on the ‘dark side’. The article was taken from the ‘Daily Reckoning’ web site. As this site gives out financial advice, my inherent cynicism of human sincerity and merit clouded my views on its veracity. At the time there was a critical comment on my view that contributors to the site were ‘snake oil salesmen’. I now think quite rightly so and withdraw, with some reservation, my comment about ‘snake oil salesmen’. However, I keep my view that politicians are ‘snake oil salesmen’. I’m with Diogenes in the adage that “It takes a wise man to discover a wise man” , and await my epiphany.

Here is my dark side post – revisited.  Bill Bonner writing from Paris for the ‘Daily Reckoning’ claimed that the US road to bankruptcy is running parallel to France. He stated that;

If you’re French you have to worry about the country going broke. There is no way they can continue to pay all those people who are retired. They seem to live forever…and they’re very expensive. France is going broke. In terms of debt and deficits the country that most resembles France is the United States of America. Both are going broke. But so are many other “European” nations…and eventually, probably all of them. The point is, most of them are going broke. Their model is exhausted. This was the social welfare model derived from Bismarck – take from workers; pay to non-workers. It was okay as long as the pool of workers was growing faster than the pool of non-workers. But that’s no longer the case.

He concluded that;

Curiously, the nation furthest along on the road to bankruptcy is a non-European nation that picked up the model early, Japan. Already, there are more people retiring in Japan than there are people entering the workforce. Overall, the population is falling, while the number of people over 65 increases at 3% per year. In 1990, there were more than 4 people working for every retiree. Now there are barely two. Practically all the European nations, and all the nations lived in predominantly by people from Europe…as well as Japan…are headed down this dead-end road.

It seems to me that the fundamental truth in all of this is that;

To take any proportion of the wealth generated by those ‘in work’ to pay for the support of those ‘not in work’,  requires that those ‘in work’ are capable of creating and maintaining  a surplus of national wealth to support such indigence.

Bonner may well be proved right. Nations are now competing in a scramble for growth, which translates into a competitive scramble for world resources to feed that growth. Further, this scramble for growth needs to increase the national wealth to enable  a social welfare programme such as is found in a European model. The politico-economic solution that you buy into, in the belief that it is the cure that allows you to continue as before, may well be snake oil. Whatever solution you buy into, the medicine that you take and its efficacy may only give a respite that is an illusion. But by the time that you find this out, the ‘snake oil salesman’ will have left town.

Author: Peter

Web researcher

5 thoughts on “A very European road to perdition -revisited!”

  1. Therew as a very apt quote on another site I read regularly…

    If something can’t go on forever, it will stop. Federal spending at these rates can’t go on forever. Or even for twenty years.

    We should note that the current crackpot government isn’t reducing our debt, merely reducing the rate of borrowing.

  2. A good number of Americans are very well aware of this fact. The US TEA Party is primarily acting out of this reason. The government became too large, debts became too large, spending is far, far too high. In a number of states, such as Wisconsin, Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky state governments have acted out of economic necessity and reality and have moved to make pension plans affordable and sustainable. The question is who will take over next year on the Federal level. There’s a good chance that it will be Rick Perry, the governor of Texas, who has presided over the country’s most successful state for ten years now. If not, probably Tim Pawlenty of Minnesota who managed to force his state’s often leftist government to live within its means, something which his leftie successor is realising is necessary — and is being penalised by his side for it.

  3. Here in Viking Utopia half of the working population depends on state income. Of the rest a high proprtion draw state benefits. It’s getting herder to work out where the tax revenues come from.

  4. Over the years I have realised that the ability of social, political and economic commentators to accurately predict the future is next to non existent. Once a society has surpassed the very basic levels of survival, wealth becomes a relative rather than absolute concept. Greece is bordering on bankruptcy. Do we honestly believe that were it to happen, the Greeks would either starve or die of disease? I do not think so. I suspect, though I recognise my ability to predict the future is no better than anybody else’s, that life will pretty much go on as before, the only difference being that a new bunch of oligarchs will emerge. Standards will drop, but instead of getting a new car every five years it might be every 10. Instead of living to 80 they may live to 78. Instead of eating meat 6 days a week, they may only have it 4 days. But largely speaking people will be relatively well fed, well educated, well housed and well medicated, compared to the inhabitants of third world countries.

  5. You are right Sipu,

    “Life will pretty much go on as before, people will be relatively well fed, well-educated, well housed and well medicated, compared to the inhabitants of third world countries”.

    The West needs economic growth to sustain even reduced expenditures. Such growth cannot continue based on historic resources and markets, for which there is now increasing competition leading (one hopes) to the betterment of ‘the third world’. However, this is not a cornucopia of resources and markets.

Add your Comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s